Scotland’s Children’s Commissioner has raised concerns over proposed restrictions on social media use for children under 16, warning that a blanket ban may not achieve the intended safety outcomes.
The warning comes amid ongoing UK government discussions on introducing stricter age limits and tighter controls on how young people access online platforms.
“Ban May Not Make Children Safer” — Commissioner Warns
The commissioner, Nicola Killean, said there is currently insufficient evidence to prove that banning under-16s from social media would significantly improve online safety.
She cautioned that such restrictions could unintentionally push young users toward less regulated and potentially more dangerous online spaces.
Instead, she urged authorities to focus on holding technology companies accountable for harmful platform designs and content systems.
Concerns Over Harmful Online Content and Algorithms
Killean acknowledged that social media platforms expose children to risks such as cyberbullying, manipulation, harmful content and contact from strangers.
However, she also noted that digital platforms can play a positive role by enabling communication, learning, self-expression and community support.
She argued that policy responses must balance protection with children’s rights and digital participation.
UK Government Reviewing New Online Safety Measures
The comments come as the UK government continues its “Growing up in the online world” consultation, which explores possible reforms to strengthen child online protection.
The review is considering measures such as minimum age limits for social media, stricter age verification, and restrictions on features like autoplay and infinite scrolling.
Officials say the findings will help shape future digital safety laws under the broader Online Safety Act framework.
Policy Debate Intensifies Ahead of Final Decisions
More than 81,000 submissions were reportedly received during the consultation period, reflecting strong public interest in the issue.
Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer has indicated that the government plans to act quickly once the findings are reviewed, describing the issue as a potential “game-changer” for online safety regulation.
